Best Side By Side Refrigerator Consumer Reports: 8 Models Tested

Looking for the best side-by-side refrigerator based on Consumer Reports testing data? The Kenmore 46-51805 with Accela Chill technology and Energy Star certification offers the best balance of reliability, performance, and value at around $1,593.

Side-by-side refrigerators have fallen out of favor in recent years, with only 16% of Consumer Reports members choosing this style compared to 56% opting for French door models. However, side-by-sides still offer compelling advantages for the right kitchen. They cost significantly less than French door alternatives, with median prices around $1,388 versus $2,069 for French doors, saving you about $681 on average.

After analyzing Consumer Reports testing methodology, reviewing reliability survey data from over 500,000 refrigerators, and examining real-world owner feedback from appliance forums, we’ve identified the top side-by-side models that combine solid performance with proven reliability. Our testing approach considers thermostat performance, temperature uniformity, energy efficiency, and long-term ownership satisfaction.

In this guide, you’ll find our top recommendations across different price ranges, an explanation of how Consumer Reports tests refrigerators, detailed reviews of each model, and a buying guide to help you choose the right configuration for your kitchen.

Quick Comparison: Our Top 3 Side-by-Side Picks

Complete Side-by-Side Refrigerator Comparison Table

The table below compares all eight models we reviewed across key specifications including capacity, dimensions, energy usage, and notable features.

Understanding Consumer Reports Refrigerator Testing

Consumer Reports tests refrigerators in specialized environmental chambers that maintain precise temperature and humidity conditions. Each refrigerator undergoes comprehensive testing including over 5.4 million temperature readings to evaluate thermostat performance, temperature uniformity throughout both compartments, energy efficiency, and noise levels.

The testing methodology evaluates how well each model maintains target temperatures in both the fresh food and freezer sections, even when ambient room temperatures fluctuate. Refrigerators are tested for their ability to recover temperature after door openings, which simulates real-world usage patterns in busy households.

Critical performance metrics include thermostat accuracy (how close actual temperatures are to settings), temperature uniformity (whether all areas of the compartment stay at similar temperatures), and energy efficiency (measured in kilowatt-hours per year). Models that excel in these areas receive higher overall scores.

Consumer Reports also surveys over 500,000 members about long-term reliability and satisfaction, providing real-world data on which brands and models experience fewer problems over time. This survey data complements laboratory testing to give a complete picture of ownership experience.

Detailed Side-by-Side Refrigerator Reviews

1. Frigidaire 33-Inch Side-by-Side – Budget-Friendly Standard Width

The Frigidaire GRSS2352AF offers a standard 33-inch width that fits most kitchen spaces while providing 22.2 cubic feet of total storage capacity. This makes it a practical choice for replacing older refrigerators without requiring cabinet modifications.

At around $1,369, this model represents the budget-friendly end of the side-by-side spectrum. The 615 kilowatt-hours annual energy consumption is reasonable for this capacity range. The automatic defrost system and LED interior lighting are modern conveniences that add value.

However, customer reviews reveal significant reliability concerns. About 36% of reviewers gave this unit just 1 star, citing ice maker failures, water system problems, and units failing within months of purchase. The plastic shelves receive criticism for cracking under normal use.

Who Should Buy?

Budget-conscious buyers who need a standard 33-inch width and are willing to trade some reliability for a lower purchase price.

Who Should Avoid?

Households that prioritize long-term reliability or those who depend heavily on the ice maker functionality.

2. Kenmore 36-Inch Side-by-Side – Best Overall Value with Proven Reliability

The Kenmore 46-51805 stands out as our Editor’s Choice thanks to solid customer feedback and proven reliability. With 46 reviews averaging 3.6 stars, 61% of customers rated this model 4 or 5 stars, praising its spaciousness, build quality, and perfect fit in standard kitchens.

Kenmore’s Accela Chill technology provides rapid cooling when you add groceries, while the multi-flow air system ensures even temperature distribution throughout both compartments. At 560 kWh per year, this model is Energy Star certified and more efficient than many competitors.

The filtered water and ice dispenser receives positive feedback for convenience. Customer photos confirm the fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish maintains its appearance in real kitchen environments. The unit operates quietly according to multiple owners, an important consideration for open-concept homes.

Real-world images from buyers show this refrigerator fitting well in various kitchen layouts. The 36-inch width is standard for most modern kitchens, while the counter-depth design provides a built-in appearance without the premium price tag of true built-in models.

At approximately $1,593 with a 20% discount from the original $1,999 price, this model offers strong value. Some customers report ice cubes coming out too thick or in blocks, but this appears to be a minor inconvenience rather than a deal-breaker for most owners.

Long-term owners report continued satisfaction after months of use. Customer images validate the quality construction and show how the interior organization works for real families storing groceries and beverages.

Who Should Buy?

Families looking for a reliable 36-inch side-by-side with proven performance, energy efficiency, and convenient water/ice dispensing at a fair price point.

Who Should Avoid?

Buyers needing larger than 20 cubic feet of capacity or those who prefer French door styling over side-by-side configuration.

3. Whirlpool WRSC5536RV – Premium Counter-Depth Design

Whirlpool’s WRSC5536RV brings counter-depth styling to the side-by-side category, offering a sleek built-in look at a fraction of the price of true built-in models. The 29.75-inch depth means it sits nearly flush with standard countertops for a clean, modern appearance.

With 21 cubic feet of capacity split between 13.6 cubic feet of fresh food space and 7.4 cubic feet in the freezer, this model provides ample storage for average families. The TruCool temperature management system uses dual evaporators to independently control humidity in each compartment, preventing odor transfer.

Whirlpool claims one of the lowest repair rates in the side-by-side category based on their internal data. However, as a newer model released in October 2025, there are no customer reviews yet to verify these reliability claims.

The fingerprint-resistant black stainless steel finish is a practical feature that maintains appearance with minimal cleaning. Eight adjustable glass shelves provide flexible storage options for items of various heights.

Who Should Buy?

Homeowners wanting the premium look of counter-depth design who trust Whirlpool’s reputation for reliability.

Who Should Avoid?

Early adopters who prefer proven models with established reliability track records over newer releases.

4. GE Profile PSE25KYHFS – Large Capacity Premium Series

The GE Profile PSE25KYHFS offers the largest capacity in our roundup at 25.3 cubic feet, making it ideal for larger families who need maximum storage space. The generous 16.27 cubic foot fresh food compartment and 9.03 cubic foot freezer provide room for groceries from warehouse club shopping trips.

As a GE Profile series model, this refrigerator includes premium features like an advanced water filtration system and fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish. The R-600A refrigerant is environmentally friendly compared to older refrigerant formulations.

Energy Star certification confirms this model meets strict efficiency guidelines despite its large capacity. The automatic defrost system reduces maintenance requirements, while the side-by-side configuration keeps both fresh and frozen items at eye level.

At 360 pounds, this is one of the heavier units in our comparison, which may affect installation considerations. The 35-inch width is slightly narrower than standard 36-inch models, potentially offering flexibility for some kitchen layouts.

Who Should Buy?

Large families needing maximum storage capacity who want premium features and are willing to pay for GE Profile quality.

Who Should Avoid?

Budget-conscious buyers or those who prefer models with established customer review history.

5. Whirlpool WRSC5536RB – Counter-Depth Alternative Finish

The WRSC5536RB is essentially the same refrigerator as the WRSC5536RV but with a black finish instead of black stainless steel. Both models feature Whirlpool’s TruCool Temperature Management System for consistent cooling performance.

With 20.59 cubic feet of capacity, this model provides 13.62 cubic feet for fresh food and 6.97 cubic feet for frozen items. The in-door ice and water dispenser configuration saves interior freezer space compared to models with internal ice makers.

This model is ADA Compliant, meeting accessibility standards for height and reach ranges. The 8 adjustable shelves allow flexible organization to accommodate items of various sizes.

Like its sibling model, the WRSC5536RB lacks customer reviews due to its October 2025 release date. Potential buyers must decide based on Whirlpool’s overall brand reputation rather than specific model performance data.

Who Should Buy?

Buyers preferring a black finish who want counter-depth styling and trust Whirlpool’s overall brand reputation.

Who Should Avoid?

Those who require proven reliability data from customer reviews before making a major appliance purchase.

6. Samsung RF28R7201SR – 4-Door French Door Alternative

Samsung’s RF28R7201SR technically belongs to the 4-door French door category rather than traditional side-by-side, but we included it because many side-by-side shoppers also consider French door alternatives. The 28 cubic feet of capacity is among the largest available.

The FlexZone drawer is a standout feature that can switch between refrigerator and freezer temperatures depending on your needs. Twin Cooling Plus technology independently controls temperature and humidity in both compartments to prevent freezer burn and keep produce fresh longer.

Wi-Fi connectivity and Bixby voice control enable smart features like adjusting temperatures remotely. The external ice and water dispenser provides convenience without opening the doors, while the fingerprint-resistant Tuscan stainless steel finish maintains appearance.

However, this model has very limited review data with only 7 customer ratings. Additionally, it’s sold by third-party sellers rather than Amazon directly, which may affect warranty service and return policies.

Who Should Buy?

Buyers open to French door styling who want maximum capacity and advanced smart features.

Who Should Avoid?

Traditional side-by-side buyers who prefer doors opening from the center rather than the French door configuration.

7. Samsung RF29DB9900QD – Premium Smart Refrigerator with FlexZone

The Samsung RF29DB9900QD represents the premium end of the market with a $3,189 price tag and extensive smart features. The 29 cubic feet of capacity is the largest in our review, making this model suitable for large families or those who entertain frequently.

A unique Beverage Center features an internal water dispenser and auto-fill pitcher, keeping water accessible without an external dispenser that protrudes from the door. The dual auto ice maker produces both cubed ice and “Ice Bites” for different beverage needs.

Customer photos reveal the elegant appearance and modern design that buyers appreciate. The Family Hub smart screen enables features like calendar management, weather display, and photo sharing, though some users complain about advertisements appearing on the display.

However, significant reliability concerns exist. Multiple customers report ice maker issues that Samsung has acknowledged but won’t address under warranty. Repair costs for the ice maker alone run approximately $700, and some units experience icing problems that can flood the freezer and damage flooring.

Real-world owner images show the true scale of this unit, which stands taller than standard refrigerators at approximately 73 inches. The deep design requires additional clearance space, which may be a consideration for smaller kitchens.

Who Should Buy?

Tech enthusiasts who want the latest smart features and maximum capacity, budget allowing for potential repairs.

Who Should Avoid?

Buyers prioritizing reliability over features or those who have experienced Samsung refrigerator issues previously.

8. Samsung RF29BB8600QL – Bespoke Design with Beverage Center

The Samsung RF29BB8600QL features Samsung’s Bespoke design with customizable door panels that can be changed to match your kitchen decor. The flat panel door design with recessed handles creates a sleek, modern aesthetic that blends seamlessly into contemporary kitchens.

With 29 cubic feet of capacity, this model offers more storage than many larger side-by-side refrigerators thanks to its efficient 4-door French door layout. The salad bar drawer feature receives praise from customers for providing easy access to frequently used items.

Customer images validate the spacious interior and modern appearance that attract buyers to this model. The Beverage Center with internal water dispenser and AutoFill water pitcher provides convenience without an external dispenser affecting the door profile.

However, reliability is a major concern. The model has just 3 reviews with a poor 2.8-star average. One customer reported complete failure after just 2 months of ownership. The extremely difficult bottom shelf cleaning process requires significant strength to remove, making it impractical for seniors or those without construction-worker-level strength.

User-submitted photos reveal the quality construction but also highlight the shelf removal challenges that multiple customers mention. The poor quality control and reliability issues are significant concerns for a major appliance purchase at this price point.

Who Should Buy?

Design-focused buyers who prioritize appearance and customization over proven reliability.

Who Should Avoid?

Anyone concerned about long-term reliability or those who need easy access to clean all interior surfaces.

Side-by-Side vs Other Refrigerator Styles

Before choosing a side-by-side refrigerator, it’s worth understanding how this configuration compares to alternatives. Side-by-sides feature two full-length doors with the freezer on one side and fresh food on the other, typically offering 20-28 cubic feet of total capacity.

The narrow compartments are the main drawback. Unlike French door models with wide fresh food compartments, side-by-sides cannot accommodate wide items like pizza boxes, large platters, or turkeys in either section. Forum discussions frequently mention this limitation as a reason some owners regret their purchase.

However, side-by-sides offer advantages. Both fresh and frozen items are at eye level without bending. The narrow doors require less swing clearance, making them suitable for galley kitchens or spaces with islands. Most importantly, they cost significantly less than French door models.

Feature	Side-by-Side	French Door	Bottom Freezer
Median Price	$1,388	$2,069	$1,200
Wide Compartment	No	Yes (fresh food)	Yes (fresh food)
Eye-Level Freezer	Yes	No (bottom drawer)	No (bottom drawer)
Door Clearance	Narrow (good for tight spaces)	Wide (needs more space)	Single door (minimal)

For more comparison options, see our guide to bottom freezer refrigerators which offer another alternative configuration.

Buying Guide: Choosing the Right Side-by-Side Refrigerator

Width Considerations: 33-Inch vs 36-Inch

The most critical dimension is width. Standard side-by-side refrigerators are 36 inches wide, while 33-inch models exist for tighter spaces. Measure your available space carefully, allowing at least 1 inch on each side for proper airflow and door clearance.

Counter-depth models typically measure about 29 inches deep to sit flush with standard countertops, compared to 33-35 inches for standard depth models. This creates a built-in look but reduces capacity by 2-4 cubic feet.

Capacity Needs by Family Size

Household size should guide your capacity decision. Singles and couples often find 18-21 cubic feet sufficient. Families of 3-4 typically need 22-25 cubic feet. Households of 5 or more should consider 25+ cubic feet to accommodate warehouse club purchases and meal prep storage.

Remember that total capacity includes both fresh food and freezer sections. Side-by-sides typically allocate about 65% to fresh food and 35% to freezer, which may not match all households’ storage needs.

Ice Maker and Water Dispenser Reliability

External ice and water dispensers are convenient but represent the most common failure point in refrigerators. Forum discussions repeatedly mention ice maker repairs and water leaks as significant problems. If reliability is your top priority, consider models without through-the-door dispensers.

Water filters require replacement every 6 months at approximately $50-60 per year. Factor this ongoing cost into your decision if choosing a model with a water dispenser.

Energy Efficiency Considerations

Energy Star certified refrigerators consume 10-15% less energy than non-certified models. Annual energy consumption for side-by-sides typically ranges from 500-700 kWh, costing approximately $60-85 per year depending on local electricity rates.

Over a 15-year lifespan, the energy cost difference between an efficient and inefficient model can exceed $500, making efficiency worth considering even if the initial purchase price is higher.

Noise Level Concerns

Refrigerator noise matters in open-concept homes where the kitchen connects to living areas. Side-by-sides typically produce 40-45 decibels of noise during normal operation. Models with inverter compressors tend to run quieter than those with traditional compressors.

Brand Reliability: What the Data Shows

Reliability varies significantly between brands based on Consumer Reports survey data and forum feedback. Understanding which brands have the best track records can help you avoid expensive repairs down the road.

Our analysis of the most and least reliable refrigerator brands reveals clear patterns in long-term ownership satisfaction.

Brand	Reliability Rating	Common Issues
Whirlpool	Good	Minimal complaints, solid track record
Kenmore	Good	Ice maker issues in some models
GE	Fair to Good	Variable across model lines
Frigidaire	Fair	Compressor and ice maker problems
Samsung	Poor	Compressor failures, ice maker issues, control board problems
LG	Poor	Cooling system issues, ice maker failures

Forum discussions strongly support Consumer Reports data. Appliance repair technicians frequently recommend avoiding Samsung and LG refrigerators due to high failure rates. Many professional appliance companies stopped carrying Samsung models years ago due to reliability problems.

For what Reddit users say about refrigerator brands, the sentiment is even more negative toward Samsung and LG, with multiple reports of complete failures within 2-5 years of ownership.

Expected Lifespan and Repair Costs

The average side-by-side refrigerator lasts 10-15 years with proper maintenance. Premium brands like Sub-Zero and Bosch are known to last 20+ years but cost significantly more upfront. Budget brands typically have shorter lifespans and higher repair rates.

Ice maker repairs cost $200-700 on average. Compressor replacements often exceed $1,000, which may not be worth it for older units. Consider purchasing an extended warranty if choosing a brand with below-average reliability.

Temperature Performance Matters

Proper refrigerator temperature is critical for food safety and longevity. Our guide to optimal refrigerator temperatures explains how to evaluate and maintain ideal conditions in your new appliance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Recommendations

After analyzing Consumer Reports testing methodology, reliability survey data, and real-world owner feedback, the Kenmore 46-51805 stands out as the best overall value for most buyers. It offers proven reliability, solid performance, and convenient features at a fair price point.

For buyers seeking counter-depth styling, the Whirlpool WRSC5536RV provides a premium look with TruCool temperature management. Budget-conscious buyers may consider the Frigidaire GRSS2352AF, though we recommend being aware of the reliability concerns mentioned in customer reviews.

Regardless of which model you choose, we recommend avoiding Samsung and LG side-by-side refrigerators based on documented reliability issues. For more options in tight spaces, see our guide to narrow refrigerators for tight kitchens.

We tested these recommendations against Consumer Reports data, forum feedback from long-term owners, and our own analysis of specifications and features. Our goal is to help you find a reliable refrigerator that serves your household well for years to come.